Board & Director Pay

Board of director compensation, built to be defended.

How a non-employee director pay program is structured, where boards are challenged on their own pay, and how we benchmark it.

Director pay

Directors set their own pay. That is the whole problem.

Director compensation is the one pay decision a board makes about itself. Every other decision in the committee’s remit has an independent party on the other side of it. This one does not, which is why courts, proxy advisors and investors look at it differently from executive pay.

The amounts are small next to the chief executive’s package, and that is usually why the program gets a light review every few years instead of a real one. The exposure is not the dollar value. It is that the people who approved the number are the people who received it.

We benchmark and design non-employee director programs for public companies, for pre-IPO companies bringing on their first independent directors, and for nonprofits deciding whether to pay their boards at all.

Structure

What a director pay program contains

Scrutiny

Where boards are challenged on their own pay

Delaware: entire fairness

In In re Investors Bancorp (2017), the Delaware Supreme Court held that when directors use their discretion to grant themselves awards under a shareholder-approved equity plan, and a shareholder properly alleges a breach of fiduciary duty, those awards are reviewed for entire fairness and not under the business judgment rule. Shareholder approval protects the board only where shareholders approved the specific awards, or where the plan is self-executing and leaves directors no discretion. Boards have responded with meaningful, shareholder-approved limits on director pay and a documented benchmarking record behind each year’s decision.

Proxy advisors: outliers and problematic practices

ISS has had a policy on excessive non-employee director pay since its 2018 policy cycle. For the 2026 proxy season it widened that policy. An adverse recommendation against the committee members who set director pay can now follow a pattern that runs across non-consecutive years, or a single year where ISS considers the practice egregious. Its examples of problematic director pay include performance-based awards, retirement benefits and excessive perquisites. The ISS equity plan scorecard now also gives credit to plans that carry a cash-denominated limit on director awards.

Disclosure

US public companies report each director’s pay in the director compensation table required by Item 402(k) of Regulation S-K, with a narrative describing the program. Because every director’s total is public, an outlier is easy for anyone to find.

Whether a particular limit or approval process gives a board the protection it wants is a question for counsel. Our part is the market data and the design.

Method

How we benchmark director pay

Other settings

Nonprofit boards and UK companies

Nonprofits

Most charities do not pay board members for board service. Where a public charity does, the amounts are reported on Form 990 Part VII, and voting members of the governing body are disqualified persons under IRS §4958, so the pay has to be reasonable for the services actually provided. Private foundations sit under the separate self-dealing rules of §4941, which permit reasonable compensation for necessary personal services. Our §4958 reasonableness review covers the record a board needs.

United Kingdom

UK practice differs. Non-executive directors are paid fees. Provision 34 of the UK Corporate Governance Code says their remuneration should reflect time commitment and responsibilities and should not include share options or other performance-related elements. In November 2025 the Financial Reporting Council updated its guidance to confirm that boards may pay part of a non-executive director’s fee in shares. We advise UK-listed companies through our London practice.

Common questions

Board and director compensation

What does a board of director compensation consultant do?

A director compensation consultant benchmarks and designs pay for non-employee directors: cash and equity retainers, committee and chair fees, stock ownership guidelines, and the limit on total director pay. Because directors approve their own compensation, much of the value of independent advice is the record it creates behind the decision.

How often should a board review director pay?

We recommend a market check every year and a full program review at least every two years, or sooner after a material change in company size, a new peer group, or a change in board leadership structure.

Should directors receive performance-based equity?

Generally no. Director equity is meant to align directors with shareholders without tying their pay to the results they oversee. ISS lists performance-based awards among the director pay practices it treats as problematic, and the UK Corporate Governance Code says non-executive pay should not include performance-related elements.

Do nonprofits pay their board members?

Most charities do not pay board members for board service. Where a public charity does, the amounts are reported on Form 990 Part VII, and voting board members are disqualified persons under IRS section 4958, so the pay must be reasonable for the services actually provided.

Does a shareholder-approved limit on director pay protect the board?

It helps, but a limit alone is not a shield. Under the Delaware Supreme Court's 2017 decision in In re Investors Bancorp, discretionary awards directors make to themselves can be reviewed for entire fairness unless shareholders approved the specific awards or the plan leaves directors no discretion. How that applies to a particular company is a question for counsel.

Related

Related guides and markets

Get in touch

Before the proxy, not after it.

Committee cycle support, pay-for-performance simulation, and CD&A drafting — at partner level throughout.

Thanks — your message is on its way. We’ll follow up shortly.
Send a message

Tell us what you’re working through and we’ll follow up directly.

Fields marked * are required. We use your details only to reply to your inquiry.